Brad Wardell's views about technology, politics, religion, world affairs, and all sorts of politically incorrect topics.
Part 2 on the background of Middle Earth
Published on December 17, 2003 By Draginol In Movies & TV & Books

In part 1 I discussed the relationship between Gandalf, Saruman, Sauron, and the Balrog.

Part II: Of Aragorn, Númenor, and third age Elves...

Thank goodness Tolkien wrote his books back when he did and not today. Because in today's climate of political correctness the coolest parts of the Middle Earth mythology have to do with the fact that not everyone is equal.  You see, there are men and then there are MEN. Aragorn, the human hero of Lord of The Rings, is not just "some guy". He's Númenorean. A very special type of man. A super man.  One Númenor could take out many normal men. The movie can't really convey just how powerful Aragorn is.

Númenor was founded by a man named Elros. Elros was Elrond's brother. That's right, Elrond is not a full elf himself and neither is his daughter Arwen.  Elros and his people did great deeds in the battle against Morgoth and as a reward, the Valar raised a huge, beautiful island in the ocean west of Middle Earth for Elros and his followers to live on.  To his followers were given unusually long life. Hundreds of years of life.  And Elros, being half elvish, chose to be human.  And Elrond chose to be elvish. It was a choice they were given long ago and they made their choices.

For awhile, Númenor prospered. But eventually it became corrupt. They began to fear death more and more. When you live hundreds of years in relative bliss and perfect health, it must be tough to deal with getting old and dying.  To make a long story short, Sauron, who could appear at that time in the guise of a good and noble person, took advantage of this and convinced the Númenoreans that they could live forever if they simply sailed off into the furthermost west where the Valar lived and conquered that. Sauron lied and claimed that it was the lands of the Valar that made the Valar live forever instead of anything inherent.

And so Númenor prepared for war. But not all.  Some of them had enough wisdom to recognize Sauron for what he was.  And so a small group of Númenoreans secretly fled to Middle Earth. These were Aragorn's ancestors. The Valar made short work of the foolish Númenorean attackers.  Sauron, who remained on the island thought himself pretty clever until the Valar decided to destroy the actual island itself in punishment for the attack. This destroyed Sauron's first body.  In time he obviously returned but he no longer had the potency of spirit to construct a body that was fair and pleasing to the eye.

Meanwhile, the Númenoreans who fled set up two kingdoms. One was called Arnor. The other, in the south, was Gondor. Elendil and his son Isildur eventually found themselves battling Sauron once he took shape again. Elendil died (we see that in the opening part of Fellowship of the Ring). Isildur took the ring but was slain by orcs (also seen).  But Isildur had children at this point. And through a line of succession we get to Aragorn.

So while the typical man might live 70 years. Aragorn can expect to live a couple hundred years.  In fact, at the time of our story, he's already in his 80s. He's been, ahem, dating Arwen (who's 3000 years old herself) for 40 years. They are the ultimate case of  waiting until you get married as both of them are chasted.

Which brings us to Elrond.  Elves get progressively wimpier as each generation passes. In fact, one of the themes of Tolkien's mythology is that things lose their potency and strength over time.  The elves created directly by Eru (Illuvitar, i.e. "God") are by far the most powerful. Think of it as the potency of their spirits being disispated through their children.  If the first elves had a potency of 10 and two of them have 5 children, then those 5 children would share a power level of 20 (so 4 each).  And so as time has gone on, that potenecy has been divided over and over again.  Of course, there is the case of Feanor who was the ONLY child of two first generation elves and as a result was actually the most powerful elf of all.

No elves of that power exist in middle earth anymore.  One of those elves could taken on Sauron one on one.  The most powerful elf left in Middle Earth is 3rd generation and that is Galadriel (Elrond is 6th generation).  Which is why you see magical things in her realm but you don't see it (as much) in Rivendell where Elrond is (except for the enchanted river but know one knows if Elrond was the one who actually did that or whether Gil-Galad or some other high elf set it up for him). But even Galadriel is a shadow of what the most powerful elves once did.

And we don't even get into the wood elves who aren't much better then normal men other than living forever and thus having a lot longer time to get good at a bow or fighting or whatever.  The thing to remember is that Aragorn, being of the race of Númenor is inherently more hardy, stronger, faster, more skilled, wiser, more intelligent, etc. than the normal man or the normal elf. The elves you see generally in the movie are butt kickers but only because they've lived so long as to be well practiced. Aragorn is a butt kicker because it's part of what he is. He is inhernetly better at pretty much everything than anyone else. Only a handful of descendents of Númenor exist such as Faramir, Boromir, and Denethor but in their cases, they are not "pure" Númenorean. Their blood is mingled with "common men" and hence their wisdom, strength, and life are shortened. But they're still far above the typical man but not as powerful as Aragorn who is the only pure blooded Númenorean left that we know of.

So when you watch Return of the King or The Two Towers and you see Aragorn perform feats that make you go "Oh yea, how would he survive that?" the issue is that the movies can't translate the vast differences in skill between normal men and one of Númenorean heritage. Aragorn is the closest thing to a super hero you're going to see out of the men of Middle Earth.


Comments (Page 2)
2 Pages1 2 
on Jan 10, 2004
i thought that after aragorn ruled for 120 yrs he died. arwen then left her children and went to lorien when she died at...geez cerith something or other, can't remember in the 121st year. also, supposedly from something else i read, elrond is descended from man and elf. he has the choice to decide mortal or immortal life, so does his children. this may explain her ability to become`"mortal" in some sense. also, from what i remember, legolas and gimli go together on a boat to valinor--i think thats what it is called.
on Jan 10, 2004
No, she's a mortal woman in the books as well at the end.
on Jan 12, 2004
Arwen is descended from the line of Earendil, who were given the chance to choose between mortal and immortal kindred, a blessing from the Valar when Earendil reached Valinor and pleaded with the Powers to help the two Kindreds against Morgoth. As such, Elros Tar-Minyatur(?) was the brother of Elrond, and he chose to be numbered among Men. His line is that of the Numenorean Kings (so yes, Arwen and Aragorn are related). Elrond however chose to be numbered among the Elves, hence his immortality. Remember that the line of Earendil and Elwing is of Elvish, Human and Maia descent (through Melian the Maia of Doriath). So Arwen has a fraction of human blood, if her mother Celebrian was pure-blooded as she was the daughter of Galadriel and Celeborn. She also has the option to choose her fate, whether to be counted as an Elf or a child of Men.

on Jan 12, 2004
You have noted that the oldest elves residing in middle earth during the 3rd Age are Galadriel and Elrond, but what about Cirdan? I cant be certain but I think it is implied that he is one of the first generation of Elves and even if not he is older than Galadriel. He was in Beleriand when the elves first began their journey into the west.
on Jan 13, 2004
I agree, Cirdan is almost certainly older than Elrond but probably not as old as Galadriel. Galadriel is the only elf, that I'm aware of, that actually was born in the west. She is really really REALLY old (15,000 years or more?)
on Jan 13, 2004
Very insightful but maybe you should have had somebody proofread your writing before you posted this. Terrible grammar and you change tenses within the same sentences. Be that as it may, I'm a new LOTR fan and thus was very interested in anything I can learn. Thank you.
on Jan 13, 2004
In regards to Cirdan, I think it might be written in the Silmarillion or is some of Tolkiens other works, but I do recall Cirdan being a lord of the Teleri (one of the 3 orders of elves the first awoke) and he was most certainly present in Middle Earth long before the Elves even began their journey into the west where Galadriel was born. And at the time the Faenor and his sons returned to wage war on Morgoth he was already a leader of the Elves of Beleriand and took an active part in the wars of the first age.
on Jan 13, 2004

Very insightful but maybe you should have had somebody proofread your writing before you posted this. Terrible grammar and you change tenses within the same sentences.

Sheesh, write your own blogs then. I'm not doing this for pay or as some sort of school paper.

on Jan 14, 2004
Great articles about Lord of the Rings! I just finished reading The Return of the King and while I was delighted to see (well, read) that Faramir and Eowyn got together (poor Faramir, with his cooky father and rash brother, I'm glad he got his girl), I was sooooo heartbroken to read in the appendices how Arwen passed away. Why didn't Arwen just choose to be Elvish (Elven?) and when Aragorn died, make a ship to Valinor, like Legolas did (and subsequently took Gimli with him)? Instead of wandering around what used to be Lorien, alone and depressed? Or at least stay with her children? Seemed like a very sad ending to her character...Can anyone shed any light on this? Thanks!
on Feb 21, 2004
good article
on Mar 03, 2004
hello
thankyou for writing this piece you have proved a point that i have been tryin to for ages and that is that aragorn is not a human. i proved lucy wrong and im not a stupid as i look ( thats a matter of apinoin)

thanx ema
on May 03, 2007
I can see where you get your inspiration for your games!
2 Pages1 2