One of the more frustrating aspects of the Internet is also one of its
strengths - it is the great equalizer. People from all walks of life can get
together and debate about anything. It is frustrating because often times you
find yourself debating on some issue you're an "expert" on with some high school
kid who has no idea what they're talking about.
I will be debating a legal point or making a business argument only to find
myself trading posts back and forth with some kid who is just plain clueless.
They say teenagers act like they know it all. But the Internet has given them a
venue to spout off their know-it-allisms to the world. Many a time I'll be
on some forum having just finished a 2 page response putting forth my argument
only to realize that the people I'm arguing with aren't even adults. Doh!
Whether the topic be intellectual property law, capitalism, business ethics,
politics, you name it, the net is full of people who will write passionately in
response despite complete ignorance on the topic. I've seen that a lot
here on JoeUser, especially in the comments area. People from the left and
right will spout off, without even being aware of it, the "talking points" of
the other side. Mindless parroting of straw man arguments and other idiocy is
all too common on the net.
So let me rant out 15 points about nothing in particular that I've found are
true but are often argued about by people who have no idea what they're talking
about.
1) Capitalism isn't perfect. But it is the best system we have. Human beings
act in their self interest and any system that wants to succeed on a large scale
has to have a way of motivating people to do work that they may not want to do
but benefits them and has the side effect of benefiting society.
2) All nations act in their own self interest but not to equal degrees.
3) The United States is the most benevolent leading world power in history.
Pointing out its misdeeds and mistakes doesn't change that. Those who disagree
need to look through history at other major powers and their actions.
4) Intellectual property law basically boils down to this: People who create
things have the right to determine those things are used and distributed.
Period.
5) Advertising will not pay for bandwidth intensive websites.
6) If you think George W. Bush or Bill Clinton are/were the worst Presidents
in American history you should stop debating history and learn history instead.
7) If you think Democrats are all atheists or that Republicans are all
devoutly Christian then you should spend more time looking into these things
rather than spouting off on things you don't know about.
8) The Declaration of Independence is not a legal document.
9) Money can be exchanged for goods and services. Despite the wishes of some
people, there is no referee who determines which jobs or careers are more worthy
than others when it comes to deciding how much they get paid.
10) It is the state governments of the United States who perform nearly all
the work that most people associate with what their tax dollars do (roads,
schools, police, services, etc.). If you're arguing that the federal
government should raise taxes so that it can do more "stuff" for the people you
need to look at what the federal government actually does.
11) More people died and suffered long term from fire bombing Tokyo in 1945
than died/suffered from the atomic bomb in Hiroshima.
12) If you have two people paying taxes and one of them pays 90% of the taxes
and the other 10% of the taxes and you give both of them a 25% cut to their
taxes, the first man will receive 90% of the overall benefit and the latter will
receive 10%. Any fair tax cut will always provide the greatest benefit to
the ones who pay the most.
13) Nearly every major world leader has some involvement with a major power.
Arguing that "evil man X" once received help or support from the United States
is idiotic because odds are same evil man X also received support from other
major powers in some way as well. Moreover, it ignores the fact that times
change. The #2 beneficiary of all time in today's dollars from American military
aid was Joseph Stalin (UK was #1). The United States sent hundreds of billions
of dollars (in today's dollars) to Stalin in World War II. Many of those
weapons, and especially trucks, were later used to do hold down Eastern Europe.
That doesn't make the US complicit.
14) Nearly all weapon systems and other military material used by Saddam
Hussein came from France and Russia -- not the United States.
15) In any argument or fight, it is rare that both sides are "equally" wrong.
In fact, most of the time, one side is definitively wrong and the other side is
right. Those who attempt to use moral equivalence arguments to describe both
parties are more interested in looking noble than acting noble.
update: renamed title to 15 common topics instead of "facts" since that was what I was getting at.