Brad Wardell's views about technology, politics, religion, world affairs, and all sorts of politically incorrect topics.
Published on August 15, 2011 By Draginol In Personal Computing

I’ve been an Outlook user for years.  But in the past several months, I’ve been migrating more and more to Gmail. The email still goes through our company server to and from ultimately but Gmail is just a better mail reader.

Here’s what’s changed:

  1. Gmail now has a way of identifying “important” emails. I don’t know how its algorithm works but it works quite well.
  2. Gmail has insanely good spam filtering.
  3. Gmail has mouse gesture support (I hold down the right mouse button and drag left or right to go to next message).
  4. Gmail has added copy and pasting of images into emails. This was a big show stopper.

The only thing I really miss outlook for is its editor.  I use outlining a lot in emails and Gmail just has nothing like that yet. 

Another nice thing about Gmail is that you don’t have to store the messages locally. This matters for tech companies in an era of patent trolling litigation and the like where you are expected to be able to quickly hand over email on a particular subject to legal.  Storing emails locally long-term is not practical.

Ironically, Windows Live mail, while visually pretty, is still very far behind.  Given how much Microsoft continues to charge for Outlook, I fear its future is in doubt.


Comments (Page 1)
2 Pages1 2 
on Aug 15, 2011

I still use Outlook for work e-mail, but yeah I agree that clients for e-mail are just lacking.  I should probably take the time to switch over.

When I was trying out Office 365, the Outlook Web version was nice, but not sure I want to pay like $10/mo or so for it.

 

 

on Aug 15, 2011

Gmail now has a way of identifying “important” emails. I don’t know how its algorithm works but it works quite well.

I use gmail, and appreciate it's really good points, but I figure they do the above by a little bit more than 'skimming/scanning' which is, I suppose, the only way it could be done prospectively. I suppose everything has pluses and minuses, though. For me, the pluses outweigh the minuses.

Sad news about Google labs, though.

on Aug 15, 2011

I'm using Outlook 2007 and like it over the others that I have used in the past. I'm not a fan of free services so have never looked at gmail, etc.

outlook will copy and paste images into the body of the email, I'm not sure if that is what you're referring to on item #4.

Storing emails locally long-term is not practical.

my wife has the same complaint and zips her closed emails every year.

on Aug 15, 2011

We use Outlook at work, but I have my outlook system setup to also copy all my mail over to my gmail account. It's not really for convenience, as we have OWA. It's not really for spam control, because we have Postini, also from Google, for filtering our email. The important email id is nice, but not a completely required feature.

The two that really made me go with GMail for this were the following.

1. Email threading. It ties reply chains together so you can see what happened prior to this message.

2. Email searching. If you try searching in outlook, it takes ages to find what you're looking for. Gmail on the other hand is nearly instant. 

on Aug 15, 2011
I have several Gmail accounts (personal, blogger and gamer accounts) and I like it over Hotmail and even Yahoo. The yahoo interface is probably the most annoying one so far. I have yet to try the latest Outlook (which I use at work) but have seen my boss use it and compared to the one I have it looks a lot better, but still prefer Gmail.

I also have a Firefox add-on called Webmail which checks all my web emails (including my yahoo and hotmail accounts) and tells me how many are there and will easily open each email on it's own tab. I've tried usuing Outlook and Thunderbird and I just rather check them online for some reason. Now more than ever that I have my Google+ account and it's linked to it.
on Aug 15, 2011

I prefer Thunderbird.

on Aug 15, 2011

I use Thunderbird to send emails from email links on the web. Other than that I use Gmail open in a browser.

on Aug 15, 2011

Gmail - Fresh, progressive and forward thinking. 

Outlook - Old, antiquated and looking backwards.

on Aug 16, 2011

When I got out of the service, the uni I went to switched from Outlook to Gmail.  Everyone loved the switch.

 

 

on Aug 16, 2011

Gmail now has a way of identifying “important” emails. I don’t know how its algorithm works but it works quite well.

That's what bothers me.  HOW.  But it is an excellent spam identifier!

on Aug 16, 2011

I agree, Gmail's come a long way and so has Yahoo's mail......still I can't get by with all my mail in the cloud. Outlook wins just by keeping it local.

Gmail also suffers by not having an equal to Outlook's Categories. I tie my calendar, contacts, tasks, emails, onenote, etc. together with categories and the best equivalent Gmail can come up with is labels and multiple calendars....not even close.

Try this in gmail...When I open Outlook I can see 2 ISP email accounts, 2 business wesbsite email accounts, 2 gmail accounts and 1 hotmail account all at the same time.....no forwarding. My filters automatically pull certain emails from all accounts and store them in the specific folders I've setup. My Outlook Today home page lists all mail, IMs, tasks, and appointments for today or up to 7 days at a glance.

If I only had 1 email account then it would probably be gmail and I probably wouldn't need Outlook.

 

edit:forgot an important part....syncing with my phone.....if the damn phone didn't tell me when and where I'm supposed to be and what tasks I have to accomplish, I'd be fishing 24/7

on Aug 16, 2011

Thunderbird for everything email here. 

on Aug 16, 2011

Don't understand why some people want to keep old emails on their local hard drive versus online. That's a lot of wasted space and it takes forever to re-download old messages if the computer needs a reformat and reinstall. Besides all of my old messages are stored on the Gmail site and are easily accessible with any browser.

on Aug 17, 2011

kona0197
Don't understand why some people want to keep old emails on their local hard drive versus online.

Depends  ... Important emails are downloaded with Thunderbird, then stored and encrypted for later, the rest stays on Gmail. Last thing I would want is someone looking into my email.

on Aug 17, 2011

Depends on what you define as important I guess. What happens if after you download and store then your PC gets messed up and needs to be reformatted? You lost that email forever.

2 Pages1 2